Trading in the Doghouse: Why a Punishment System Pays off

This is a trading article, I promise, but let me tell you first off that my dog is in really big trouble right now. You see, we've got rules around here, and he went and broke one of them…badly! And, because we also have a reward and punishment system that we follow, he got punished for what he did. (Although, since I was the one who had to clean it up, I got punished, too!)

Table of Contents

That wasn't like him at all. He knows better, but rules are rules, and there are consequences for breaking them. And if that sounds to you anything like Forex trading, well, good; because it should!

The very same concept of having a reward and punishment system to help new traders promote only desired behaviors is every bit as valid. You break a rule, you get punished…simple as that!

Now hopefully your consequences don't involve a whack on the nose, or not being allowed in the bedroom that night, although if they do, tell me, how does that work for you? All jokes aside, though, what is your reward and punishment system for trading, and perhaps more importantly, are you doing a good job enforcing it?

  • Learn to focus on what you can control to be successful

  • How rewarding yourself helps become disciplined

  • Why trading rules make you more successful!

Best Award Winning Brokers

Show Search Filters
  • is a reputable trading platform, famous in the social trading industry. In 2018, the brand decided to conquer the US market and launched the local brand there. First, the company functioned solely as a crypto trading broker. Yet, later it added other items to its list of tradeable assets. Therefore, now it offers stocks and ETF trading as well. 

    With a history dating back to 2007, eToro has amassed a large user base across more than 140 countries. When cryptocurrency emerged, the brand used a unique chance to enter the American market.

    One of its key features is CopyTrader, the social trading tool and a proprietary product of the project. It allows novices to repeat trades from top traders with just a few clicks. Thus, the tool offers a fresh approach to this asset class.

    This guide aims to provide a comprehensive eToro review to help traders make informed decisions.

    etoro USA

    eToro offers trading services across many regions worldwide including the USA

  • OANDA ( boasts of a high level of trust and reliability, as evidenced by its impressive Trust Score of 93 out of 99. While OANDA is not a publicly traded company nor does it operate as a bank, it is subject to regulation by seven Tier-1 regulators, signifying a highly trusted status. Additionally, it is supervised by one Tier-4 regulator, which means that users should utilize a cautious approach to risk management.

    OANDA Corporation is regulated by the CFTC/NFA. OANDA is a member Firm of the NFA (Member ID: 0325821). CFDs are not available to residents in the United States.
  • A standalone copy-trading ecosystem, providing equities, foreign exchange, commodities and cryptocurrencies markets. Provides a global selection of brokerages.

Don't Just Have a Punishment System, Enforce it!

Have a Punishment System...And Enforce It!I have to say, at first, I got angry, and then I looked to make excuses for why it happened, why it wasn't his fault, or whether I should let it slide "just this once."  Inevitably, we all face those same thoughts and emotions following losing trades or anytime we break a rule, right? That's a natural reaction, and our way of trying to dodge the punishment system. After all, nobody really wants to face difficult truths, or own up to the fact that they were wrong. As humans, we're not programmed to want to punish ourselves—or our dogs—but this is one way that trading often requires us to go against natural instincts.

See also: Conventional Trading Wisdom That Contradicts Itself

Make sure you're not rationalizing your own bad behavior or faulty trading habits! If you ran a stop, chased after news and economic data, or traded a sub-par trade set-up or one that's not normally part of your arsenal, it's not enough to say, "OK, I know that was wrong and I won't do it again."

Rules are rules, remember? And that's why you have to enact your punishment system and pay the price for what you did. Even more than that, though, this is how you ensure that you learn from the mistake, give yourself real incentive to not do it again, and truly improve as a disciplined trader.

So whether you have to shut down and not trade anymore that day, or maybe even that week, then so be it. If it means you have to relegate yourself back to demo trading to work on specific trading skills and use proper discipline, then so be it. You have rules for a reason, and a punishment system in place to make sure you follow them. So really ask yourself, "Am I being strict enough when it comes to trading by the rules?"

And Have a Reward System, Too

Reward and Punishment SystemLet's not be one-sided and only talk about the bad stuff! Indeed, having—and actually using—a reward system is also a great way to promote desired behaviors. It's a natural and much-needed complement to any punishment system…plus it's much more fun to use! A word of caution, though: Don't make yours be all about money! Try not to specifically reward yourself for achieving "x" amount of money in your account, or having a certain number of winning trades, or booking a certain winning percentage. That could make you alter your methods in pursuit of those objectives, and potentially cause undue risk, produce losing trades instead, and make a greater need for your punishment system in the process.

It's actually much better to minimize money and end results, focusing instead on the factors you can control and the overall process that produces results. You can use monetary rewards, but do it for such things as one full week's worth of perfect plan compliance, where you trade your trading strategy precisely and right down to the finest detail for an entire week, with no exceptions. You may not even win every trade—nor do you have to with scalping trading—but when you follow the rules, you get rewarded, and that's what a reward and punishment system is all about!


Reward & Punishment SystemSo my dog was bad, and then I was mean. Basically, everybody lost when you look at it that way. It's like in trading, after you make a mistake and it ends up costing you money, you can't help but think that the monetary loss is bad enough, so why make it even worse by imposing a punishment system? Well, that does make sense, but the answer is because it's all in the interest of continually learning and improving. In the markets, and in the world of dog training, every trading mistake—when handled correctly—is a learning experience that shouldn't adversely affect the entire month or ruin the year. Everyone will get over it, and then be even better for it! And besides, just look at that face…it's gonna be hard for me to stay mad at him for long!

You May Also Like…